ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini: which AI should power your shop’s chatbot?

OpenAI, Anthropic, Google, Mistral or DeepSeek? How to choose the AI behind your WooCommerce chatbot on accuracy, speed, cost and privacy, not hype.

  • 5 min read
On this page
  1. What actually matters for a shop chatbot
  2. The main providers, briefly
  3. A simple way to choose
  4. Keep the chat running when a provider has an outage
  5. Privacy checklist for EU shops
  6. How this works in E-commerce AI Assistant

When you add an AI chatbot to a shop, someone has to write the answers. That someone is a large language model from a provider such as OpenAI (the company behind ChatGPT), Anthropic (Claude) or Google (Gemini). The plugin is the interface; the model is the brain.

The good news: for a shop, the choice matters less than the headlines suggest. Answering “do you ship to Spain?” from your own policy text is well within the reach of every major model. The differences are in cost, speed, tone, language and how your customers’ data is handled. This article goes through each.

What actually matters for a shop chatbot

Forget benchmark leaderboards. A support chatbot has a narrow, practical job, so judge models on five things:

  1. Faithfulness to your facts. Does it stick to your knowledge base and catalogue, or does it improvise a returns policy you do not have?
  2. Speed. Customers expect an answer in a few seconds. Small, fast models usually feel better in a chat than large, slow ones.
  3. Cost per conversation. You pay the provider per amount of text processed. A much cheaper model is often good enough for shop questions.
  4. Language and tone. If your customers write in French, German or Italian, the replies must read naturally in that language, not like a translation.
  5. Privacy. Every message, plus your knowledge base and the order a customer looked up, is sent to the provider. Where it is processed and whether it is kept matters, especially in the EU.

The main providers, briefly

OpenAI (GPT models, the engine of ChatGPT). The most widely used option, with a range from small, very cheap models to large, capable ones. The small models are a sensible default for shop questions: fast, inexpensive and good at following instructions. This is the provider the free version of E-commerce AI Assistant runs on.

Anthropic (Claude). Known for following instructions closely and for a careful, natural writing style. A good fit when tone matters, for example for a premium brand, or when your instructions are long and detailed.

Google (Gemini). Fast models with low-cost options and very large context windows, which helps when your knowledge base is long. Mind the tier: outside the EU, the UK and Switzerland, prompts sent through Google’s free tier may be used to improve Google’s products, while paid use is not. For shops in the EU, the UK and Switzerland, Google applies its paid-service data terms to all use.3

Mistral. A French company based in Paris,5 which some EU shops prefer for data-protection reasons. Its models handle French and other European languages well.

DeepSeek. Very low prices. Its privacy policy states that data is stored on servers in the People’s Republic of China,4 which many European shops will want to weigh before sending customer conversations there.

Others. Meta’s Llama, xAI’s Grok and Alibaba’s Qwen models are also available through their providers, and a custom endpoint lets you use any service that speaks the OpenAI format.

ProviderBased inIn E-commerce AI Assistant
OpenAIUnited StatesFree and Pro
Anthropic (Claude)United StatesPro
Google (Gemini)United StatesPro
MistralFrancePro
DeepSeekChinaPro
Meta, xAI, Alibaba, custom endpointVariousPro

A simple way to choose

  1. Start with a small, inexpensive model from a mainstream provider. For most shops it handles the everyday questions well.
  2. Write down 20 real questions your customers ask: shipping, returns, sizes, a specific product, an order.
  3. Ask them in your chat with the first model, then switch model and ask again. Read the answers side by side.
  4. Keep the cheapest model that answers them all correctly, in the right tone and language.
  5. Read a week of real conversations before deciding anything else. Real questions are always a little different from the ones you imagined.

If an answer is wrong, check the knowledge base before blaming the model. In most cases the fact simply was not there.

Keep the chat running when a provider has an outage

Every provider has outages from time to time. If the chat depends on one provider and it goes down, customers get an error message instead of an answer.

A fallback provider solves this: if the main provider returns an error or an empty reply, the same message is retried automatically with a second provider. Choosing two different companies (for example OpenAI as primary and Anthropic or Google as fallback) protects you against an outage at either one.

Privacy checklist for EU shops

Before you connect any provider, check:

  • Training: are API messages used to train models? OpenAI and Anthropic say they do not train on API data by default,12 and Google does not for paid use;3 read the current terms all the same.
  • Retention: how long are messages kept, and can you ask for less?
  • Location: where is the data processed, and is an EU option available?
  • Contract: does the provider sign a data processing agreement (DPA)?
  • Your privacy policy: tell customers that the chat uses an AI provider and name it.

E-commerce AI Assistant helps on its side: IP addresses can be hashed, conversations are deleted after the retention period you set, and the WordPress privacy tools can export or erase a customer’s chat data on request.

How this works in E-commerce AI Assistant

  • Free plan: OpenAI, with your own API key and your choice among all of OpenAI’s chat models.
  • Pro: nine providers (OpenAI, Anthropic, Google Gemini, DeepSeek, Mistral, Meta, xAI, Alibaba and any custom endpoint) with an automatic fallback provider.
  • On both: a cost estimator projects your monthly bill from your conversation volume, so you can compare models before you switch.

You pay the provider directly, at their prices, with no mark-up from us.

Sources

Figures and statements from other organisations, as published on the date shown.

  1. OpenAI, “Business data privacy, security, and compliance”, openai.com/business-data/ (accessed 18 November 2026).
  2. Anthropic, “Commercial Terms of Service”, www.anthropic.com/legal/commercial-terms (accessed 18 November 2026).
  3. Google, “Gemini API Additional Terms of Service”, ai.google.dev/gemini-api/terms (accessed 18 November 2026).
  4. DeepSeek, “Privacy Policy”, cdn.deepseek.com/policies/en-US/deepseek-privacy-policy.html (accessed 18 November 2026).
  5. Wikipedia, “Mistral AI”, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mistral_AI (accessed 18 November 2026).

By the E-commerce AI Assistant team

Keep reading

Sales

Recovering abandoned carts in WooCommerce without annoying your customers

Most WooCommerce carts are abandoned. Here is how to win some back with a well-timed chat message and a capped discount, without nagging shoppers.

5 min read

Customer service

“Where is my order?”: answering it automatically in WooCommerce

“Where is my order?” fills support inboxes. Let customers check their WooCommerce order status and tracking in the chat, securely, without waiting for you.

4 min read

Give your shop an assistant that knows your catalogue

Install the free plugin, connect your OpenAI key and answer your first customer in about 20 minutes.